Sunday, January 6, 2013


THE DEMISE(?) OF AMERICAN EDUCATION

 For years now, we have read screaming headlines that advise us that American students are falling behind the world in educational accomplishment and we must IMMEDIATELY ….. act to correct the problem. And the …. starts the debate. The purpose of this posting is to stimulate discussion in a respectful manner and continue a Facebook discussion awhile back where I learned a great deal about various items including the varieties of charter schools available.

 Back in the middle of the 20th century the American public education was the envy of the world. Even the segregated schools systems of the South produced competent graduates both black and white. So what has gone wrong?

            There is discussion that teaching accrediting qualification standards have changed to a point that diminishes the educative process. Too much time is spent on education courses and not enough on the subject matter the student will eventually be teaching. As an anecdotal aside, one of my daughters was a student at a Northern Virginia high that is a perennial pick in the top 25 high schools in the country. She was selected for an AP American History class her senior year. She graduated and went on the college. She began to repeatedly call me for help with her advanced history course. I asked her why and found out that her “teacher” had not gotten through more than 50%of the required curricula the previous year. When I pulled the string, a year too late for sure, I found out that the AP American History “teacher “had been a first year education major with no history background. Definitely my mistake as a parent.

            Another talking point is the rise of teachers unions which some say are a detriment in that poor performers are continued to be employed and promoted thus leaving less money to attract younger talent and also provide a bad example to other teachers. An example of this is the National Education Association which used to be an organization that included parents and teachers who did more than pay lip service to looking out for the students interest. Today it is nothing more than a trade union.

Money is, of course, a prime topic. The USA has the highest per capita “investment” in education approximately $13000/student. (This obviously varies from locale to locale but this seems to be the accepted figure by both sides of the debate). The results appear to be quite limited and discouraging. American students have mediocre results compared to other countries, 27th in math, for example. I have learned recently that many countries, particularly in Asia, only report the results from the elite schools which certainly would skew these surveys since the USA reports all students. But as anyone who has to deal with today’s high school, and, increasingly, college graduates, can tell you there is a large gap in the required knowledge level to succeed and that which our graduates have attained. Not a good “investment.”

 Since our parents’ generation retired from the scene, what have we done to spoil what was once the best system in the world?

            Both my parents were high school teachers. They and their colleagues were underpaid but extremely dedicated. And my generation learned. One of the most telling statistics for me today is that of relative generational reading comprehension. Today’s average 12th grader reads and comprehends at the level of a 1965 8th grader and a 1945 6th grader. This being said studies are underway to try to determine if “screen” reading vice paper may be a contributing factor. Since reading is the foundation of all learning, this has to be considered a critical item.  This decline has many practical applications that I can attest to. I spent 42 years either on active duty or working for the Navy. In 1970, the equipment technical manuals were written to the then 8th grade level and sailors were trained as technicians with troubleshooting and repair skills expected. Today the manual are written to a 6th grade level and the personnel are only trained as operators. Contractors (many of them retired 1970 sailors) do the repairs. Yet all the services brag about the fact that they have the highest number of high school graduates that they have ever had, but….

            Over the years I have done dozens of job interviews with prospective employees and I have noted the decrease in their proficiency. They no longer can write or speak in full sentences and proper grammar is non-existent. Companies cannot afford to hire these people and have them embarrass their clients. And the government itself is not immune from this decline. As my geezer generation retires, the youngsters filling our shoes are not intellectually capable to assimilate data and extrapolate items in an expeditious manner.

 My brother, Jim, has a rather unique explanation for the decline in the elementary school systems. In a word, Feminism. Now don’t giggle and become defensive because his subsequent explanation made a lot of sense. In the 1930’s and 40’s intelligent and ambitious women were stifled. There were very few women doctors, lawyers or engineers. These women were presented with a choice of teaching or nursing. My generation was blessed to be taught by bright women who didn’t like the sight of blood.

And now the main question, how to solve the problem, how to right the ship? I have heard from so many of my family and friends that are in the teaching profession that a major, if not the major, obstacle is a lack of parental involvement. And this problem crosses all economic and social strata. It is not germane to any culture or locale. Aside from PR campaigns, I have no idea how to attack this attitude. I think that a dedicated teacher could maybe pick up the slack for one or two students a year but no more than that or they hit the “burnout” that we read  about so much lately.

But, of course, we have hundreds of studies with hundreds of answers. Yet the decline seems to continue. The government answer is more money. More teacher training, more teachers. But as we have learned money is a finite quantity. Many states have realized that a teaching certificate does not a teacher make and are revising their systems to insure that teachers are qualified to teach the subjects they are assigned. There will be no more secondary education majors teaching AP American History at W.T. Woodson High School in Annandale Virginia. The question of more teachers is a little harder for me to understand. My small Pennsylvania home town has a historical Facebook page. Recently, folks have been posting those composite grammar school pictures that were all the rage in the 50’s. In variably, there is the teacher with at least 30 kids and usually more. No teacher’s aides etc. Just grumpy old Mrs Gueder and 33 monsters (one of which was my youngest brother). Amazingly, all those kids in that, by today’s standards, was an overcrowded classroom got sufficient education to lead full and productive lives.

A possible solution being discussed is rewarding proficient teachers with bonus pay of one form or another. Teachers unions seem dead set against this. From what I gather to them it’s a “fairness” issue. Teachers shouldn’t have to be competitive etc. But I submit that the only fairness issue here should be fairness to the students. If a teacher goes over and above the minimum requirements and achieves success, they should be rewarded and the underachievers lose out. If the sharp young effective teacher is let go and the old fogie just putting in time for retirement is retained because of the union’s last hired first fired rules the kids and the school system are the losers.

And finally, we get to the major change is the education system over the generations the involvement of the Federal government. Back in the 50’s and early 60’s the Feds weren’t involved. The states and the locales funded their systems fully. Today, they fund 70-80% with the Federals picking up the rest. Put that 20% has made all the difference in that the Feds now dictate policy. Fortunately, the Bush-Kennedy No Child Left Behind fiasco is showing the fallacy behind this involvement. One size does not fit all and many states are receiving waivers from the more onerous requirements.

Another option has cropped up. Teacher certs similar to lawyer bar exams. A thought to be processed.

            In my recent exposure to this topic I have learned that, for sure, one size and one solution does not fit all locales. Please feel free to educate me.

No comments:

Post a Comment